Pillar: Widening participation and spreading excellence
Opening Date:
Deadline: Thu, 7 Mar 2024 17:00:00 (Brussels local time)
Modification Date: Mon, 24 Jul 2023
Latest information:
The evaluation of the first-stage proposals submitted in response to the call HORIZON-WIDERA-2023-ACCESS-01 (first-stage) was made looking only at the criteria ‘Excellence’ and ‘Impact’, in accordance with General Annex F of the Work Programme.
The threshold for each criteria was 4 points. The overall threshold (applying to the sum of the two individual scores) was set at a level that allowed the total requested budget of proposals admitted to stage 2 be as close as possible to 3 times the available budget (and not below 2.5 times the budget): 8.5 points.
The results of the evaluation are as follows:
Number of proposals submitted (including proposals transferred from or to other calls): 125
Number of inadmissible proposals: 0
Number of ineligible proposals: 1
Number of withdrawn proposals: 1
Number of above-threshold proposals: 47
Total budget requested for above-threshold proposals: EUR 662,745,625.00
Number of proposals invited to stage-two: 35
Total budget requested for proposals invited to stage-two: EUR 494,770,625.00
We will inform shortly the applicants about the evaluation results for their proposals.
In order to best ensure equal treatment, successful stage 1 applicants do not receive the evaluation summary reports (ESRs) for their proposals, but this generalised feedback with information for preparing the full proposal.
Main shortcomings found in the stage 1 evaluation (from successful proposals):
EXCELLENCE
Strategic vision:
● too broadly defined, scope and ambitions too wide-reaching and insufficiently focused
● state-of-the-art not suitably referenced; advancement beyond the state-of-the-art not convincingly demonstrated
● novel and innovative aspects not sufficiently highlighted
● approaches to achieving the stated goals not properly defined
Challenges:
● specific challenges for both the research discipline and/or the region not fully discussed
● some proposals address either scientific or operational challenges, but not both
Human resources:
● staff recruitment and retention approaches not appropriately addressed
● lack of concrete and attractive incentives to recruit and retain staff
Autonomy:
● insufficient information provided to demonstrate autonomy
● decision-making mechanisms, distribution of responsibilities, management bodies and independence from existing structure(s) not adequately addressed
Synergies:
● existing or potential synergies with EU/national/regional funds and policies not clearly or sufficiently identified
● no adequate description of how projects will work with or add value to policy instruments
Objectives:
● measurability of the objectives often not assured
● no or insufficient number of suitable indicators (KPIs) to verify achievement
● objectives not sufficiently linked to subsequent actions and activities
Partnership:
● interaction and mutual benefits between coordinator and advanced partner(s) not always appropriately described
● engagement and commitment of the advanced partner(s) not fully demonstrated
IMPACT
Requirements, barriers, mitigations:
● inadequate analysis of barriers to impact achievement
● lack of well-defined and robust mitigation measures
Long-term self-sustainability:
● insufficiently convincing plans for long-term sustainability
● insufficient leverage of business opportunities / IP exploitation
In the stage 2 evaluation, successful proposals will have the chance to address or clarify these issues:
– Full proposals will be evaluated more in-depth and by an extended group of independent experts
– Full proposals must be consistent with the stage-one proposal; and shall NOT differ substantially
For questions, please contact the Research Enquiry Service.














