Nur la Angla en Arizona Usono
From: Steven Graham Belant <email@example.com>
Subject: Nur la Angla en Arizona Usono
Cc: Steven Graham Belant <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII
I communicate worldwide in an Steve <email@example.com> Mi komunikas monde
international second language __ _ _ __ _ _ _ ___ _ internacidualingve
allowing us all to relate |_ (_ |_)|_ |_)/_|| | / allasante al cxiuj
to one another as equals. |__._)| |__| | || | | _/ ni rilati egalule.
Info & Free Mail Course: <firstname.lastname@example.org> or ftp ftp.netcom.com /pub/elna
San Francisco Chronicle
Thursday, December 8, 1994
Page A3, Column A
"English-Only Initiative Found Unconstitutional"
Arizona’s "official English" initiative, which requires
state and local governments to conduct virtually all
business in English, violates public employees’ freedom of
speech, a federal appeals court ruled yesterday.
At state may be entitled to promote unity by encouraging use
of a common language but cannot do it by outlawing other
languages, said the U.A. Court of Appeals in San Francisco
in a 30-to-0 ruling.
Judge Stephen Reinhardt said the initiative also interferes
with the ability of non-English speakers to receive
information and makes government less effective.
Attorney General Grant Woods said he does not plan to
appeal, although he will ask Governor Fife Symington whether
he wants to challenge the ruling.
The initiative’s sponsor, Arizonans for Official English,
will either seek a rehearing or appeal to the Supreme Court,
said the groups’s chairman, Robert Park.
The measure was approved in 1988 by 50.5 percent of the
voters but has never been enforced. Opponents sued the day
after the election in 1990, and U.S. District Judge Paul
Rosenblatt ruled the measure unconstitutional of free-speech
The court said 17 other states have "official English" laws,
but they differ from Arizona’s in that they appear to be
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
HOW TO REACH THE EDITORIAL PAGES
Editorial Page Editor Jerry Roberts 415-777-7124
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Letters are subject to condensation. They must include
signature, mailing address and telephone number.
SEND LETTERS TO:
Letters to the Editor,
San Francisco Chronicle
901 Mission Street,
San Francisco CA 94103
Letters editor 415-777-7183
OPEN FORUM ARTICLES
Articles should be 650 words or less. They must include the
writer’s signature, mailing address and telephone number.
Authors selected for publication will be notified. No
articles will be returned without a self-addressed, stamped
Open forum editor Dean Wakefield can be reached at
415-777-6023 between 2 and 5 p.m.
FAX FOR LETTERS TO THE EDITOR OR OPEN FORUM ARTICLES